
10 Marketing Myths Everyone Should ReThinc
It’s hard to believe that ReThinc Advertising has been in business for nearly twenty years. It started with three like-minded, but differently skilled, people with the conviction to create, run, and grow a ‘different’ kind of agency.
Over the years, we’ve been blessed to work with all kinds of wonderful people. From clients to vendors, we’ve been blessed to work with the very best people ever. We’ve also run into a very small group of folks I’d characterize as having challenging preconceptions regarding marketing.
Thankfully, they’ve been few and far between.
The one thing that these ‘exceptions’ had in common was a misplaced belief in one or more of the following marketing myths. It’s worth sharing these myths so you make the best decisions possible when making marketing decisions for your company and/or working with an agency to propel your brand to success.
Myth 1: “If I build a website, customers will come.”
A website is a marketing tool, not a marketing strategy. At ReThinc, we build quite a few websites. Some are remodels, some are brand new … all of them are built to make your brand visible in search and functional in providing a positive user experience that leads to conversion.
But a website in and of itself will not provide people with a reason to find you. A relevant value proposition that is driven by either need or want does. This is where your strategic outreach (SEO, digital ads, social media, email marketing, referrals, and other marketing efforts) becomes crucial.
Myth 2: “Marketing is posting on social media.”
Well, yes and no. Social media can be a highly effective component of your marketing efforts, but it is rarely a standalone. Successful marketing is achieved through an integrated approach that delivers relevant ads to relevant audiences. Social audiences will tire quickly of your brand if all you do is sell on their scroll.
Myth 3: “More followers means more customers.”
When it comes to your brand, popularity is good, but connection is better. What you want is consumers who purchase and advocate for your brand.
An engaged audience that’s genuinely interested in your business will always outperform a larger audience that simply follows because you have cute employees.
Myth 4: “SEO is something you do once.”
Search engine optimization is a process. It’s a process that responds to market conditions, competition, consumer habits, and changing algorithms.
Optimize your site and keep it relevant in the eyes of search and AI platforms by creating helpful content, keeping your site updated, and adapting your value proposition to match consumer demand.
Myth 5: “If my product or service is good enough, it will sell itself.”
It’s important to note that the quality of the product and service is a critical benchmark. Having a great product or service is an absolute necessity.
That being said, it won’t always grow your business. There are ways to minimize your outreach and help compel word-of-mouth conversions. Read my blog about it here.
Myth 6: “Marketing should produce instant results.”
Advertising is a process, not an event. Depending on your product, your value proposition, and your budget, you can most certainly get an immediate response if that’s what is warranted.
A better, more sustainable approach is to formulate a strategy that you can implement over time that builds top-of-mind awareness, consumer conversion, and customer loyalty. Brands that stay consistent outperform others who are seeking overnight success.
Myth 7: “A rebrand just means getting a new logo.”
Your logo is most certainly a key component of your brand, but it is by far not the only one. A true rebrand is a reset for your brand voice, your website, collateral assets, and most importantly, the customer experience.
Changing your logo and not implementing other internal and external improvements falls short of the true impact a rebrand should have.
Myth 8: “ Negative reviews are always bad.”
In today’s advanced digital marketing world, a negative review is oftentimes looked upon as ‘just a keyboard warrior taking out their frustrations on your business.’ For the brands we serve, we see it as an opportunity to improve by addressing a shortcoming that makes the customer journey a better one.
Also, how you respond to a negative review is yet another opportunity to make a positive impression on potential customers. Reviews aren’t just feedback. They are a chance to demonstrate your customer service in public.
Myth 9: “We tried marketing once, but it didn’t work.”
This is a tough one. At ReThinc, we take a comprehensive approach to your marketing needs. At the same time, we are sensitive to your budget, your industry, the economy, and your goals. We’ll pass on business if we can’t get alignment, but not every agency is willing to do that.
I can say this with a great deal of certainty. Marketing works when it is done correctly. To do marketing correctly, an agency must put transparency over profit when dealing with their clients.
Myth 10: “Anyone can do marketing.”
This is actually true. Anyone can engage in the activities associated with marketing. Google ads, paid social, AI search, email, traditional media placement, and other marketing executions are not rocket science. The strategy, creativity, analytical analysis, and psychology associated with making this efficient and effective are best left to professionals.
These myths are really just a small sample of the misinformation that is common in every professional practice. At ReThinc, we understand that past experiences, opinions, and what you read on the internet can be confusing and misleading. We never take it personally when a client or prospective client carries forward misinformation that either precludes us from helping them or makes the process a little more challenging.
If you’re paying for a service, you should question everything until you’re satisfied that you are being properly served. There is truly nothing wrong with that. We welcome the opportunity to explore your needs while addressing any preconceptions you may have.
Ed thanks you for taking the time to read this month’s blog. If you want to discuss your perspective on marketing or how ReThinc can help your business market more effectively, reach out to him at ed.olsen@rethincadvertising.com.



